N97 / N82 / HTC Magic Camera Comparison

by Ben Smith on 4th June 2009

  Comment Icon31

Initial impressions coming soon, but in the meantime - since lots of people were asking about the camera - here’s some comparison shots between the N97 and Nokia’s previous top-performing camera phone (in my opinion) the N82…. oh and the HTC Magic as a mid-range benchmark (and kicks, but mostly as a benchmark).

It’s not a scientific comparison by any means, but the shots represent real-world outdoors usage - snatching shots in a hurry amidst the tourist crowds, purely handheld and accepting all the default options. To my eyes the N97 pips it visually (just) on the colouring of the images - quality’s trickier to call. However it beats the N82 hands-down for ease of use, taking around 3 to 5 seconds to start the camera from cold (versus over 10 secs on my N82) and shooting / focussing much more quickly too. Battery-wise taking and uploading this identical set of images via Shozu exhausted the entire N82 battery - the N97 was still showing over 80% at the same point.

Take a look at this Flickr set for all the images.

N97, N82 and HTC Magic Camera Comparison Images - click the image to see the gallery

N97, N82 and HTC Magic Camera Comparison Images - click the image to see the gallery

  • http://www.womworld.com/nokia/9852/n97-camera-compared/ WOM World / Nokia » Blog Archive - N97 camera compared

    [...] he gets his teeth into a proper review, Ben Smith from The Really Mobile Project has taken some comparison shots with the N97, and put it up against the N82 and the HTC [...]

  • http://www.sleekmobilephones.info/mobile-phones/n97-camera-compared/ N97 camera compared | Sleek Mobile Phones

    [...] he gets his teeth into a proper review, Ben Smith from The Really Mobile Project has taken some comparison shots with the N97, and put it up against the N82 and the HTC [...]

  • MarkW

    Well, whichever you decide is the best image (close call between N82 and N97, IMHO) this demonstrates that the quality of the camera isn’t going to be a deal-breaker for anyone considering the N97. I might be considering it. I might be considering that I want one *this minute*!

  • jai

    I do love my n82, but it’s tiny screen and crappy keyboard do frustrate me.

    Glad to know i can upgrade to an n97 without losing any image quality… well in the daylight at least

  • Anonymous

    Does N97 use dual LED supported by a supercapacitor?
    In this document you can read how that kind of LED flashes could be better than xenon:

    http://www.philipslumileds.com/pdfs/CS09-xenon_vs_LED_flash.pdf

    Can you show us some pics taken in the dark (low light and even no light)?
    Thank you in advance

  • http://www.mobilephonesnow.info/?p=3170 Latest Mobile & Cell Phones » Blog Archive » Nokia N97 Camera Samples

    [...] he is toying with the phone and promises a review soon. In the mean while he has posted some comparative photo samples from the Nokia N97, N82 and HTC magic. He feels that the camera of N97 is better than that of the N82, which is like the best camera [...]

  • MarkW

    Well, whichever you decide is the best image (close call between N82 and N97, IMHO) this demonstrates that the quality of the camera isn't going to be a deal-breaker for anyone considering the N97. I might be considering it. I might be considering that I want one *this minute*!

  • MarkW

    Well, whichever you decide is the best image (close call between N82 and N97, IMHO) this demonstrates that the quality of the camera isn't going to be a deal-breaker for anyone considering the N97. I might be considering it. I might be considering that I want one *this minute*!

  • jai

    I do love my n82, but it's tiny screen and crappy keyboard do frustrate me.Glad to know i can upgrade to an n97 without losing any image quality… well in the daylight at least

  • jai

    I do love my n82, but it's tiny screen and crappy keyboard do frustrate me.

    Glad to know i can upgrade to an n97 without losing any image quality… well in the daylight at least

  • JC Rivas

    Does N97 use dual LED supported by a supercapacitor?In this document you can read how that kind of LED flashes could be better than xenon:http://www.philipslumileds.com/pdfs/CS09-xenon_…Can you show us some pics taken in the dark (low light and even no light)?Thank you in advance

  • JC Rivas

    Does N97 use dual LED supported by a supercapacitor?
    In this document you can read how that kind of LED flashes could be better than xenon:

    http://www.philipslumileds.com/pdfs/CS09-xenon_…

    Can you show us some pics taken in the dark (low light and even no light)?
    Thank you in advance

  • http://www.blackphoebe.com/msjen Ms. Jen

    Hi Ben,

    Good on you for doing this, I love side by side photo comparisons.

    Now the big question is a side by side comparison with the N82, the N86, and the N97.

    ;o)

  • http://jbrasco.wordpress.com/2009/06/05/nokia-n97-review-by-steve-litchfield-molto-interessante-video-by-telefonino-net-e-intervista-a-nokia-italia-sulle-caratteristiche-e-funzioni-del-dispositivo-cap Nokia N97: review by Steve Litchfield molto interessante | Video by Telefonino.net e intervista a Nokia Italia sulle caratteristiche e funzioni del dispositivo | Capacità fotografiche di N97 / N82 / HTC Magic messe a confronto « johnnybrasco’

    [...] fare 31 un fotoconfronto che mette in gara sulle capacità fotografiche di N97 / N82 / HTC Magic, il tutto by Ben Smith, [...]

  • http://www.blackphoebe.com/msjen Ms. Jen

    Hi Ben,Good on you for doing this, I love side by side photo comparisons.Now the big question is a side by side comparison with the N82, the N86, and the N97.;o)

  • http://www.blackphoebe.com/msjen Ms. Jen

    Hi Ben,

    Good on you for doing this, I love side by side photo comparisons.

    Now the big question is a side by side comparison with the N82, the N86, and the N97.

    ;o)

  • http://thereallymobileproject.com/ Really Mobile

    No problem… given the effort the police have gone to in London to associate owing lots of phones with terrorism I did wonder if pulling out three to repeatedly photograph soldier on guard duty was wise, but they seemed to take it in their stride…!

    I have no doubt the N86 will out-perform the N97 camera-wise overall - the pictures we got off the prototype we had were very promising, but 8MP images are going to be painful to get off a handset over the air so I think it will be things like low-light performance that are the deciders for N-series fans. Normobs will just choose on form factor…

  • Dr.Cochambre

    Excellent comparison! I can see now that i won’t regret when I change my n82 for the n97.
    This has been really helpfull.

  • http://www.tecnophone.it/2009/06/05/nokia-n97-vs-nokia-n82-vs-htc-magic-qualita-fotografica-a-confronto/ Nokia N97 Vs Nokia N82 Vs HTC Magic : qualità fotografica a confronto | Tecnophone, tecnologia e cellulari per tutti i gusti!!

    [...] sito Inglese thereallymobileproject, ha pubblicato una serie di scatti molto interessanti con questi 3 terminali [...]

  • http://thereallymobileproject.com/ Really Mobile

    No problem… given the effort the police have gone to in London to associate owing lots of phones with terrorism I did wonder if pulling out three to repeatedly photograph soldier on guard duty was wise, but they seemed to take it in their stride…!I have no doubt the N86 will out-perform the N97 camera-wise overall - the pictures we got off the prototype we had were very promising, but 8MP images are going to be painful to get off a handset over the air so I think it will be things like low-light performance that are the deciders for N-series fans. Normobs will just choose on form factor…

  • http://thereallymobileproject.com/ Really Mobile

    No problem… given the effort the police have gone to in London to associate owing lots of phones with terrorism I did wonder if pulling out three to repeatedly photograph soldier on guard duty was wise, but they seemed to take it in their stride…!

    I have no doubt the N86 will out-perform the N97 camera-wise overall - the pictures we got off the prototype we had were very promising, but 8MP images are going to be painful to get off a handset over the air so I think it will be things like low-light performance that are the deciders for N-series fans. Normobs will just choose on form factor…

  • Dr.Cochambre

    Excellent comparison! I can see now that i won't regret when I change my n82 for the n97.This has been really helpfull.

  • Dr.Cochambre

    Excellent comparison! I can see now that i won't regret when I change my n82 for the n97.
    This has been really helpfull.

  • http://www.nokiausers.net/forum/nokia-n97/27621-n97-n82-htc-magic-camera-comparison.html#post216272 N97 / N82 / HTC Magic / Camera Comparison

    [...] / N82 / HTC Magic / Camera Comparison Some interesting comparison shots HERE … Click through for more examples… __________________ This is a ‘Family-Friendly’ forum and [...]

  • http://mickyfin.vox.com/ Micky

    N97 photos not looking to bad at all.

  • http://mickyfin.vox.com/ Micky

    N97 photos not looking to bad at all.

  • http://mickyfin.vox.com/ Micky

    N97 photos not looking to bad at all.

  • http://www.titidirectonline.co.uk/mobile-phones Dual Sim Mobile Phones

    nice

  • http://www.titidirectonline.co.uk/mobile-phones Dual Sim Mobile Phones

    nice

  • http://www.bulkcameras.net/ bulk_cameras

    Great! Thank for information, I'm looking for it for a long time,

  • http://www.bulkcameras.net/ bulk_cameras

    Great! Thank for information, I'm looking for it for a long time,

Previous post:

Next post: