From N95, to E75 and beyond. Where next?

by Vikki Chowney on 29th January 2010

Here we are again; I find myself deliberating which phone to move on to next.

Post-E71 meltdown last year (RIP), I took a step backwards and reverted to my trusty N95 8GB. All was well, as I truly believe that it’s best content creator out there for a blogger. I loved being able to take such high quality photos again, its ease of use and rich media functionality.

Where do I go?

That is, until it went walkabout (I say ‘walkabout’, but really I just left it on a tube). Chowney FAIL.

As it happens, I’d been toying with which handset to get once I was eligible for an upgrade on 3 (which happened on January 16th) for some time. I’d fallen in love with the N900 in Helsinki on the N86 Tour, mainly because of the image quality, light sensitivity and beautiful transitions. It was a pre-production model, so there wasn’t much to go on, but I was impressed.

However, once it was actually released and I got to spend any amount of time with it, I was disappointed with how cumbersome it grows to feel after using for any length of time. Quite apart from the strange positioning of the unlock button and low battery life.

Back to square one. For a long time I toyed with an iPhone, almost solely to get Spotify as an app. I don’t care about the extra cost, the ability to access whatever music I want while out and about is invaluable to me. I’m nervous of battery though, but as this was a major factor in not going for the N900, it would be foolish to overlook it. However, I’ve spent time playing with the iPhone. It’s easy, it works, it does what it says on the tin. Will I miss the amazing camera quality? Probably. Could I just get the S60 app for Spotify? Definitely.

Where does this leave me? I feel the need to venture onto new ground instead of go the easy route and get another N95. The Palm Pre was - quite frankly - one of the worst phones I’ve ever used. I don’t trust Sony Ericsson, and can’t bring myself to turn to Samsung.

While I come to my decision, I’ve been using the E75, which I pretty much dismissed last year due to keyboard-related tactile reasons. Back then, I was waiting for the E72 (which was another let down sadly, it crashes too frequently for my liking) but loved the new Nokia messaging that was so simple to connect. In hindsight (it’s a wonderful thing), I was a bit harsh. I’m actually getting on alright with the 75, the email is fantastic, I’m just not using the keyboard at all. It seems a bit of a waste.

And so, we come to Android. I had a lot of fun with the HTC Hero when it was first released. I think I might just go for it. The touchscreen is fantastic, the apps are great, and I can roll a Spotify sub into a new contract with 3 if needed.

Now I just have to decide whether to stick or twist in terms of network…

  • http://davidcarrington.co.uk David Carrington

    Go fish!

    Sorry, couldn’t resist :D

  • MarkW

    I have something of a similar dilemma. When my N95 8GB died a sad death I replaced it with a HTC Hero to play with while waiting for the N900. On arrival the N900 disappointed, so I didn’t bother. Now I have a Hero I absolutely love - except for the utterly useless camera.

    I hear though that the Nexus One has a great camera. If they’ve finally got that cracked on an Android it could be the closest thing to an ideal device for some time…

  • http://www.intomobile.com/ Constantine

    The conclusion that I’m really hearing is that the E71 stole your heart and the industry has failed to make something comparable. It’s been almost 2 years since that thing came out too.

  • http://brendandonegan.wordpress.com/ Brendan

    “The Palm Pre was - quite frankly - one of the worst phones I’ve ever used.”

    Huh. American websites would have you think it’s amazing and that the solution to Nokia’s ‘problems’ is to replace Symbian with WebOS.

  • Guest

    1. Nexus One
    2. iPhone 3GS
    3. E71

  • jke

    1. Nexus One
    2. iPhone 3GS
    3. E71

  • http://www.techsociotech.com FJ!!

    If the E71 works, it works. If it is 2 years old, it will be cheap to snap up, while we find out what is in the pipelines close to release.

  • http://twitter.com/TheProdigalFool The Prodigal Fool

    Vikki - I’d love to hear more about why you dislike the Palm Pre so much. I’ve only played with it briefly but - hardware issues aside - I found it one of the more impressive devices I’ve seen for a long time.

    But back to your dilemma…

    It’s a damning indictment of Nokia’s current product portfolio that you have a dilemma at all. The choice should be obvious but, I see your problem, it isn’t.

    The E72 should have been a no-brainer if you’re an E71 fan but, as you say, the software issues put paid to that.

    My take on it is that - pound for pound - you can’t buy a better smartphone than the iPhone 3GS. I know, I know, it’s just jumping on the bandwagon but, honestly, even for geeks like me (and you?), it terms of real-world use, it’s the best thing going. The battery is a weakness for sure but invest in an extra cable and dock for plugging it in when you’re at your desk at work and that problem disappears.

    Go on, jump on in. The water’s warm.

  • @mydogminton

    I’m happy with my Hero, however…. still waiting for HTC to update Touchflow with Android 2. Also, the camera is rather slow and, in anything other than daylight, quite dark.

  • http://davidcarrington.co.uk David Carrington

    Go fish!Sorry, couldn't resist :D

  • http://davidcarrington.co.uk David Carrington

    Go fish!

    Sorry, couldn't resist :D

  • MarkW

    I have something of a similar dilemma. When my N95 8GB died a sad death I replaced it with a HTC Hero to play with while waiting for the N900. On arrival the N900 disappointed, so I didn't bother. Now I have a Hero I absolutely love - except for the utterly useless camera.I hear though that the Nexus One has a great camera. If they've finally got that cracked on an Android it could be the closest thing to an ideal device for some time…

  • MarkW

    I have something of a similar dilemma. When my N95 8GB died a sad death I replaced it with a HTC Hero to play with while waiting for the N900. On arrival the N900 disappointed, so I didn't bother. Now I have a Hero I absolutely love - except for the utterly useless camera.

    I hear though that the Nexus One has a great camera. If they've finally got that cracked on an Android it could be the closest thing to an ideal device for some time…

  • http://www.intomobile.com/ Constantine

    The conclusion that I'm really hearing is that the E71 stole your heart and the industry has failed to make something comparable. It's been almost 2 years since that thing came out too.

  • http://www.intomobile.com/ Constantine

    The conclusion that I'm really hearing is that the E71 stole your heart and the industry has failed to make something comparable. It's been almost 2 years since that thing came out too.

  • http://brendandonegan.wordpress.com/ Brendan

    “The Palm Pre was - quite frankly - one of the worst phones I’ve ever used.”Huh. American websites would have you think it's amazing and that the solution to Nokia's 'problems' is to replace Symbian with WebOS.

  • http://brendandonegan.wordpress.com/ Brendan

    “The Palm Pre was - quite frankly - one of the worst phones I’ve ever used.”

    Huh. American websites would have you think it's amazing and that the solution to Nokia's 'problems' is to replace Symbian with WebOS.

  • jke

    1. Nexus One2. iPhone 3GS3. E71

  • jke

    1. Nexus One2. iPhone 3GS3. E71

  • jke

    1. Nexus One
    2. iPhone 3GS
    3. E71

  • jke

    1. Nexus One
    2. iPhone 3GS
    3. E71

  • http://www.techsociotech.com FJ!!

    If the E71 works, it works. If it is 2 years old, it will be cheap to snap up, while we find out what is in the pipelines close to release.

  • http://www.techsociotech.com FJ!!

    If the E71 works, it works. If it is 2 years old, it will be cheap to snap up, while we find out what is in the pipelines close to release.

  • http://twitter.com/TheProdigalFool The Prodigal Fool

    Vikki - I'd love to hear more about why you dislike the Palm Pre so much. I've only played with it briefly but - hardware issues aside - I found it one of the more impressive devices I've seen for a long time.But back to your dilemma…It's a damning indictment of Nokia's current product portfolio that you have a dilemma at all. The choice should be obvious but, I see your problem, it isn't. The E72 should have been a no-brainer if you're an E71 fan but, as you say, the software issues put paid to that.My take on it is that - pound for pound - you can't buy a better smartphone than the iPhone 3GS. I know, I know, it's just jumping on the bandwagon but, honestly, even for geeks like me (and you?), it terms of real-world use, it's the best thing going. The battery is a weakness for sure but invest in an extra cable and dock for plugging it in when you're at your desk at work and that problem disappears.Go on, jump on in. The water's warm.

  • http://twitter.com/TheProdigalFool The Prodigal Fool

    Vikki - I'd love to hear more about why you dislike the Palm Pre so much. I've only played with it briefly but - hardware issues aside - I found it one of the more impressive devices I've seen for a long time.

    But back to your dilemma…

    It's a damning indictment of Nokia's current product portfolio that you have a dilemma at all. The choice should be obvious but, I see your problem, it isn't.

    The E72 should have been a no-brainer if you're an E71 fan but, as you say, the software issues put paid to that.

    My take on it is that - pound for pound - you can't buy a better smartphone than the iPhone 3GS. I know, I know, it's just jumping on the bandwagon but, honestly, even for geeks like me (and you?), it terms of real-world use, it's the best thing going. The battery is a weakness for sure but invest in an extra cable and dock for plugging it in when you're at your desk at work and that problem disappears.

    Go on, jump on in. The water's warm.

  • @mydogminton

    I'm happy with my Hero, however…. still waiting for HTC to update Touchflow with Android 2. Also, the camera is rather slow and, in anything other than daylight, quite dark.

  • @mydogminton

    I'm happy with my Hero, however…. still waiting for HTC to update Touchflow with Android 2. Also, the camera is rather slow and, in anything other than daylight, quite dark.

  • Anonymous

    OK, same boat until a week ago, first N95, very very hard to beat, then E71 and love it (well, except the crappy camera), time to change went to E72, totally let me down. Tried the Milestone, very good besides the fact that Exchange support is horrible, seriously horrible even paying for a replacement app.
    So, endend up with the N97 mini, so far very well, get the great camera again, most of the software tweaks in the E71 (agenda, contacts, nokia messaging and so on) present plus a great 360×640 screen. So far very stable, so far happy with it.

  • netborn

    OK, same boat until a week ago, first N95, very very hard to beat, then E71 and love it (well, except the crappy camera), time to change went to E72, totally let me down. Tried the Milestone, very good besides the fact that Exchange support is horrible, seriously horrible even paying for a replacement app.So, endend up with the N97 mini, so far very well, get the great camera again, most of the software tweaks in the E71 (agenda, contacts, nokia messaging and so on) present plus a great 360×640 screen. So far very stable, so far happy with it.

  • netborn

    OK, same boat until a week ago, first N95, very very hard to beat, then E71 and love it (well, except the crappy camera), time to change went to E72, totally let me down. Tried the Milestone, very good besides the fact that Exchange support is horrible, seriously horrible even paying for a replacement app.
    So, endend up with the N97 mini, so far very well, get the great camera again, most of the software tweaks in the E71 (agenda, contacts, nokia messaging and so on) present plus a great 360×640 screen. So far very stable, so far happy with it.

  • http://www.ubervu.com/conversations/thereallymobileproject.com/2010/01/from-n95-to-e75-and-beyond-where-next/ uberVU - social comments

    Social comments and analytics for this post…

    This post was mentioned on Twitter by mack005: “From N95, to E75 and beyond. Where next?” - http://is.gd/7hkAK...

  • http://www.thoughtsfromhell.net Michael Hell

    i know that feeling vikki, Nokia has nothing really exciting to offer (N900 excluded). Everything kinda feels the same with a little tweak here and there. Android seems like a good Option for you, i’d even go as far and recommend you the Nexus One over the Hero, as it’s a good Upgrade to have..

    fantastic article :)

  • Anonymous

    Cheers DC, helpful… ;)

  • Anonymous

    I’m actually going to be trialling a Hero next week, glad to hear you’re such a fan. The camera might be an issue though. Even though the E75′s is just over 3MP, it’s pretty good.

  • Anonymous

    Pretty much…

  • Anonymous

    No. It really was terrible. Incredibly unintuitive and near impossible to navigate.

  • Anonymous

    I haven’t played with a Nexus yet, so couldn’t comment, but it’s possible…

  • Anonymous

    Sure, but the camera is awful and the E72 hasn’t fixed the problem.

  • Anonymous

    How?! It’s one of the most unnatural navigation structures I’ve ever seen. It’s unresponsive AND slow. I don’t want to bang on about it, but I couldn’t believe it was released with such fanfare. Each to their own though!

    I’m still considering the 3GS, it’s not out of the running just yet! I just have to wait and see if 3 offers it to me for another 18 months of my money.

  • Anonymous

    Same as the E71. Drove me crazy in the end.

  • Anonymous

    I’ve used an N97 and a mini version in the past, but can’t get on with the touchscreen I’m afraid. Not up to scratch in my eyes.

  • Anonymous

    Thank you! I’m thinking it’s now a choice between the iPhone 3GS, Hero and Nexus One. Stay tuned :)

  • JamesVincent

    Just one thing! Stay away from Samsung. Charging the S8300v everyday is awfull!

  • http://www.thoughtsfromhell.co.cc Michael Hell

    i know that feeling vikki, Nokia has nothing really exciting to offer (N900 excluded). Everything kinda feels the same with a little tweak here and there. Android seems like a good Option for you, i'd even go as far and recommend you the Nexus One over the Hero, as it's a good Upgrade to have.. fantastic article :)

  • http://www.thoughtsfromhell.co.cc Michael Hell

    i know that feeling vikki, Nokia has nothing really exciting to offer (N900 excluded). Everything kinda feels the same with a little tweak here and there. Android seems like a good Option for you, i'd even go as far and recommend you the Nexus One over the Hero, as it's a good Upgrade to have..

    fantastic article :)

  • vchowney

    Cheers DC, helpful… ;)

  • vchowney

    Cheers DC, helpful… ;)

  • Anonymous

    I reviewed a Hero about a month ago, I am trying an iPhone at the moment and today got hands on a Nexus One for the first time.

    Without doubt the Nexus One just blew me away, the screen is massive but in a thin body so you get a lightweight phone with some great features. The Hero is good, it has a good run with Android but maybe time to hand over the flagship name to the Nexus I think.

    As for the iPhone, It’s…..ok. It does basics well but you have to rely on Apple far too much for things even ringtones and STILL no flash and STILL no multi-tasking!.

    My thoughts have to be even after using a Nexus for just a few minutes today was what an awesome phone it is and I highly recommend one.

  • vchowney

    I'm actually going to be trialling a Hero next week, glad to hear you're such a fan. The camera might be an issue though. Even though the E75's is just over 3MP, it's pretty good.

  • vchowney

    I'm actually going to be trialling a Hero next week, glad to hear you're such a fan. The camera might be an issue though. Even though the E75's is just over 3MP, it's pretty good.

  • vchowney

    Pretty much…

  • vchowney

    Pretty much…

  • vchowney

    No. It really was terrible. Incredibly unintuitive and near impossible to navigate.

  • vchowney

    No. It really was terrible. Incredibly unintuitive and near impossible to navigate.

  • vchowney

    I haven't played with a Nexus yet, so couldn't comment, but it's possible…

  • vchowney

    I haven't played with a Nexus yet, so couldn't comment, but it's possible…

  • vchowney

    Sure, but the camera is awful and the E72 hasn't fixed the problem.

  • vchowney

    Sure, but the camera is awful and the E72 hasn't fixed the problem.

  • vchowney

    How?! It's one of the most unnatural navigation structures I've ever seen. It's unresponsive AND slow. I don't want to bang on about it, but I couldn't believe it was released with such fanfare. Each to their own though!I'm still considering the 3GS, it's not out of the running just yet! I just have to wait and see if 3 offers it to me for another 18 months of my money.

  • vchowney

    Same as the E71. Drove me crazy in the end.

  • vchowney

    How?! It's one of the most unnatural navigation structures I've ever seen. It's unresponsive AND slow. I don't want to bang on about it, but I couldn't believe it was released with such fanfare. Each to their own though!

    I'm still considering the 3GS, it's not out of the running just yet! I just have to wait and see if 3 offers it to me for another 18 months of my money.

  • vchowney

    Same as the E71. Drove me crazy in the end.

  • vchowney

    I've used an N97 and a mini version in the past, but can't get on with the touchscreen I'm afraid. Not up to scratch in my eyes.

  • vchowney

    I've used an N97 and a mini version in the past, but can't get on with the touchscreen I'm afraid. Not up to scratch in my eyes.

  • vchowney

    Thank you! I'm thinking it's now a choice between the iPhone 3GS, Hero and Nexus One. Stay tuned :)

  • vchowney

    Thank you! I'm thinking it's now a choice between the iPhone 3GS, Hero and Nexus One. Stay tuned :)

  • JamesVincent

    Just one thing! Stay away from Samsung. Charging the S8300v everyday is awfull!

  • JamesVincent

    Just one thing! Stay away from Samsung. Charging the S8300v everyday is awfull!

  • worldofnokia

    I reviewed a Hero about a month ago, I am trying an iPhone at the moment and today got hands on a Nexus One for the first time.Without doubt the Nexus One just blew me away, the screen is massive but in a thin body so you get a lightweight phone with some great features. The Hero is good, it has a good run with Android but maybe time to hand over the flagship name to the Nexus I think.As for the iPhone, It's…..ok. It does basics well but you have to rely on Apple far too much for things even ringtones and STILL no flash and STILL no multi-tasking!.My thoughts have to be even after using a Nexus for just a few minutes today was what an awesome phone it is and I highly recommend one.

  • worldofnokia

    I reviewed a Hero about a month ago, I am trying an iPhone at the moment and today got hands on a Nexus One for the first time.

    Without doubt the Nexus One just blew me away, the screen is massive but in a thin body so you get a lightweight phone with some great features. The Hero is good, it has a good run with Android but maybe time to hand over the flagship name to the Nexus I think.

    As for the iPhone, It's…..ok. It does basics well but you have to rely on Apple far too much for things even ringtones and STILL no flash and STILL no multi-tasking!.

    My thoughts have to be even after using a Nexus for just a few minutes today was what an awesome phone it is and I highly recommend one.

  • jamesbody

    FWIW - my current working configuration is E71 (for voice - both on GSM and Truphone - hard to beat), HTC Hero (for doing lots and lots of things at once - but let down by the camera) and a iPod Touch/Huawei MiFi combo (pricipally for e-mail/Twitter and general iTunes Apps goodness).

    As ever I still carry the odd dozen or so handsets - but the tree above are the ones that I rely on to communicate with.

    I have as yet resisted the temptation to take out a second mortgage for either the iPhone 3GS (I shall await the update later this year) or the N900 (price and difficulty in getting apps)

  • http://topsy.com/tb/is.gd/7hkAK Tweets that mention The Really Mobile Project » Blog Archive » From N95, to E75 and beyond. Where next? — Topsy.com

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Sloan Bowman, Shazly Makeen and David Schlesinger, Fakhr-E-Alam. Fakhr-E-Alam said: RT @mack005: "From N95, to E75 and beyond. Where next?" - http://is.gd/7hkAK [...]

  • http://twitter.com/jamesbody James Body

    FWIW - my current working configuration is E71 (for voice - both on GSM and Truphone - hard to beat), HTC Hero (for doing lots and lots of things at once - but let down by the camera) and a iPod Touch/Huawei MiFi combo (pricipally for e-mail/Twitter and general iTunes Apps goodness).As ever I still carry the odd dozen or so handsets - but the tree above are the ones that I rely on to communicate with.I have as yet resisted the temptation to take out a second mortgage for either the iPhone 3GS (I shall await the update later this year) or the N900 (price and difficulty in getting apps)

  • http://twitter.com/jamesbody James Body

    FWIW - my current working configuration is E71 (for voice - both on GSM and Truphone - hard to beat), HTC Hero (for doing lots and lots of things at once - but let down by the camera) and a iPod Touch/Huawei MiFi combo (pricipally for e-mail/Twitter and general iTunes Apps goodness).

    As ever I still carry the odd dozen or so handsets - but the tree above are the ones that I rely on to communicate with.

    I have as yet resisted the temptation to take out a second mortgage for either the iPhone 3GS (I shall await the update later this year) or the N900 (price and difficulty in getting apps)

  • Anonymous

    Trust me I will :)

  • vchowney

    Trust me I will :)

  • vchowney

    Trust me I will :)

  • http://www.r4ds.sk/ cheap Nintendo DS r4 karty

    I have e75, but I don’t like it because you have to pull the phone out completely, so there’s not much difference with carrying it in a pocket. I know the slider keyboard is a problem for a case, but maybe some manufacturer has already thought of that.

  • http://www.r4ds.sk/ cheap Nintendo DS r4 karty

    I have e75, but I don't like it because you have to pull the phone out completely, so there's not much difference with carrying it in a pocket. I know the slider keyboard is a problem for a case, but maybe some manufacturer has already thought of that.

  • http://www.r4ds.sk/ cheap Nintendo DS r4 karty

    I have e75, but I don't like it because you have to pull the phone out completely, so there's not much difference with carrying it in a pocket. I know the slider keyboard is a problem for a case, but maybe some manufacturer has already thought of that.

  • Anonymous

    I’m a little late to the party but oh well.

    I’m actually surprised that people find the N900 a disappointment, I thought it was just me. Everything I read about it (even after release) made it seem amazing. Now it’s sat next to me being clumsy and boring. I hate it. Worst thing is, Nokia won’t take it back because it isn’t faulty.

    Motorla Milestone/Droid is next on my list, depending on what is annouced at MWC. I feel it’s about time to give Android a go, and after using the N900 I need a full QWERTY keyboard.

    I had an E71 for about 4 months, until the camera made me what to cry every time I took a picture, it truly is rubbish.

    iPhone 3GS is amazing, I had one for 6 months till I finally got bored of it. The lack of flash is the only problem I had with it. The camera on it is actually really really good.

    So, I think you should get the Motorola Milestone and then tell me all about it so I can decide if it’s worth me getting :D

  • thegnarlypanda

    I'm a little late to the party but oh well.I'm actually surprised that people find the N900 a disappointment, I thought it was just me. Everything I read about it (even after release) made it seem amazing. Now it's sat next to me being clumsy and boring. I hate it. Worst thing is, Nokia won't take it back because it isn't faulty.Motorla Milestone/Droid is next on my list, depending on what is annouced at MWC. I feel it's about time to give Android a go, and after using the N900 I need a full QWERTY keyboard.I had an E71 for about 4 months, until the camera made me what to cry every time I took a picture, it truly is rubbish.iPhone 3GS is amazing, I had one for 6 months till I finally got bored of it. The lack of flash is the only problem I had with it. The camera on it is actually really really good.So, I think you should get the Motorola Milestone and then tell me all about it so I can decide if it's worth me getting :D

  • thegnarlypanda

    I'm a little late to the party but oh well.

    I'm actually surprised that people find the N900 a disappointment, I thought it was just me. Everything I read about it (even after release) made it seem amazing. Now it's sat next to me being clumsy and boring. I hate it. Worst thing is, Nokia won't take it back because it isn't faulty.

    Motorla Milestone/Droid is next on my list, depending on what is annouced at MWC. I feel it's about time to give Android a go, and after using the N900 I need a full QWERTY keyboard.

    I had an E71 for about 4 months, until the camera made me what to cry every time I took a picture, it truly is rubbish.

    iPhone 3GS is amazing, I had one for 6 months till I finally got bored of it. The lack of flash is the only problem I had with it. The camera on it is actually really really good.

    So, I think you should get the Motorola Milestone and then tell me all about it so I can decide if it's worth me getting :D

  • http://thereallymobileproject.com/2010/03/do-i-need-a-hero/ Do I need a Hero? — The Really Mobile Project

    [...] part of my ongoing search to find a new phone, those lovely folk at 3MobileBuzz recently sent me an HTC Hero to try [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: